Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
ArticlesDiving DestinationsLearning Scuba DivingMarine LifeMiscellaneous
Discussion GroupsGeneralScuba EquipmentScuba LocationsAustralian ScubaUK Scuba
DirectoryScuba Clubs

Scuba Forum / Scuba Locations / July 2004

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

MV Hurricane - Marsa Alam, Egypt - Report

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Submersible Sid - 15 Jun 2004 20:10 GMT
Hi everyone,
I have just returned from a week liveaboard on the MV Hurricane, one
of the Tornado Marine's newest boat ( or so they say ). I booked this
boat as an upgrade from the MV Excel, which i had sailed on 12 months
ago.
I booked the trip through Tony Backhurst Scuba at www.scuba.co.uk and
paid 1095GBP. The boat is advertised as the ultimate liveaboard and
brand new on the website.I was told by Tony Backhursts that it was put
to sea at the end of May 2004 and I was part of the second group
aboard since it's "launch"
When i arrived at the dock in Egypt i was convinced that the boat was
a re-fit. The exterior of the boat was covered in heavy rust in many
places and had the overall appearance of a boat that had been in use
at sea for some time.
Parts of the interior seemed new ( furnishings, etc ) and there had
definitely been a paintbrush waved around the interior too, however
the decking seemed old and many parts of the structure were rusty too.
The cabins were disappointingly small and the en-suite bathroom was
almost unusable due to the ridiculously small size of it. When i
opened the door to the bathroom I had to squeeze in, stand in the
shower cubicle, and then close the door before i could use the WC! The
cabins did not have a bar/TV or sound system as advertised and were
seriously lacking in storage space ( only 1 small wardrobe ) There was
a smell of sewage all week in the cabins too.
There were many teething problems whilst i was on board too. Many of
the A/C units leaked heavily onto the cabin beds, saloon seating and
dining room tables/chairs. The nitrox fills were constantly
inconsistent, sometime up to 2% out from the requested fill. The ribs,
which were advertised as jet propelled, were in fact outboards and
there wasn't a PC, fax or e-mail available in the saloon as advertised
either
Overall, in my opinion, the boat was not a patch on the much older MV
Excel. The only plus point was that the crew and guides ( sonia and
grant ) were fantastic. The food was tasty and plentiful too.
Deadulus,Elphinstone, Rocky and St Johns have changed dramatically
since my last visit ONLY 12mnths ago. When i travelled there last year
we were the only boat on most of the sites and very rarely saw another
boat during the trip. This year was completely different and we very
rarely saw less than 5 boats ( sometimes up to a dozen ) sharing the
same small site. Needless to say most of the big stuff has
disappeared, leaving once teaming reefs devoid of shoaling hammerheads
and large groups of pelagics. It's a real shame that the Egyptian
government does not have the foresight to limit the number of boats
per site at any one time, like many other countries currently employ.
This area is already over subscribed with visitors, yet a second
weekly flight from the UK starts soon.
Given the expense incurred I could not recommend this trip / boat,
especially considering where else you can get to in the world for the
same price. This is, of course, only one mans opionion.
Safe diving...

Submersible Sid

"Opinions are like arseholes. Everyone has one, but you don't
necessarily want to hear it."
Dorset Mark - 17 Jul 2004 11:59 GMT
Hurricane Update

I read with some alarm Sid's report last week, as I was about to go one
trip
on MV Hurricane.

Having returned yesterday (15/7) I though I should put my view.
Hurricane
is great and if you are about to travel on it please don't worry -
you'll
have a great time.

I have been on Excel, Susanna 1, VIP One and Royal Emperor in the last
couple of year so consider that I have some experience in quality
live-boards.

So what is great.

Well the food is fantastic and the staff are great.  The cabins are
equipped
with fridges that work, DVD and TVs that work and the air con is great
in
the cabins.  Cabin size is plenty big enough, with adequate storage
which
can cope with your empty dive bags.  Extra draws have been built into
the
bed bases now.  The dinning area is spacious and well laid out, the
upper
saloon is also well laid out with a huge plasma screen, DVD and music
centre, with a well equipped bar with plenty of ice.  The upper sun deck
has
plenty of room and even a Jacuzzi -  honest!  The lower shaded deck is
very
spacious and comes with plenty of seating and tables.   The kitting up
area
is big enough for all the divers to kit up simultaneously and includes
some
nice touches, like a camera table.  The large dive platform comes with
covered
camera tank and two fresh water showers.  This is a luxury
live-aboard!

Be assured the boat is new and I saw no real sign of rusting, a point
to
note is that all boats rust - from the moment the keel is laid down and
as a
result repainting is a constant task to keep a steel boat is shape.
Neither
was there any sign, to me, that the boat had been at sea for any length
of
time.

The decking all looked new to me and although I did notice that is a
couple
of small places the paintwork had been touched up or not expertly
applied
when originally painted, although I had to look for this and would not
have
noticed unless I had seen Sid's post.

So what is not perfect.

Well the air con in the dinning rooms and the main saloon works, but
is
either inadequate or was not working to its full capacity, I think it
was
the latter.  It does cool these areas, but not as well as I might have
expected.  The bathrooms; this was the cause of some discussion, I am
told
that they are the same size as Suzanne 1 and Royal Emperor, but not as
big
as Excel and I think that is about right.  What is different is the
shape,
they have tried to separate the WC, washbasin and shower into
different
areas and the net result is you have a longer narrow bathroom.  On a lot
of boats
the shower tends to soak the whole bathroom, on Hurricane it doesn't.
However this narrow space is then exacerbated by a door that opens into
the
bathroom and hits the WC before opening fully.   I expect that the
doors
will changed to open into the cabin and this will help.  What you must
know
is that the bathrooms do work and were quite adequate.

Some of Sid's other points

Nitrox mixes, I used it all week and it did vary, by up to 1% and on a
couple of occasions nearly 2%, but it was made very clear to me that if
it
was out that they would adjust the mix before I dived, frankly I
didn't
bother, but reset my computer accordingly.  Overall I have no
complaints
about the Nitrox.  What I would say is that on previous live-aboards we
have
had bad tasting fills, on Hurricane the fills both air and Nitrox were
dry
and odour free.

I think Sid's comments about jet drive and PC and email facilities are
based
on last year's information, which we saw as we were originally going to
use
it last year, but couldn't and as it wasn't finished.  The latest
information does not make any mention of jet drives or PC availability.

The Ribs are new and very well equipped - the best I have seen on any
boat.
As for email the GSM signal only works when you are close to the port
but
after that the comms is limited to SAT phone.

The Southern Red Sea -Elphinstone, Deadulus, Zabagad, Rocky Island,
Fury
Shoal and St Johns.  I have dived this area four times in the last two
years, it is getting busier and much as I would like to be the only boat
on
any site this is not going to happen in the future. Frequently one or
two
other  boats accompanied us, but on occasions we were alone.   My advice
is
go now as it'll only get busier, if you want deserted sites try Sudan.
However the sites are still great for seeing sharks, we saw white
tipped,
greys and hammerheads.  The reefs and coral gardens are stunning and
not
over dived - yet.  This is still the place to go as far as I am
concerned
and I will do Sudan once I am confident that the country is safe.

What you must understand is that the boat is new and frankly in some
areas
the boat is still being 'shaken down'.  What is impressive is the way
that
staff dealt with any minor problems that we had.  The staff were
insistence
that we reported anything that was not working perfectly, I can only
assume
that as time goes on that any last remaining imperfections will be
rapidly
resolved.

So would I go on Hurricane again? - YES!

--
Dorset Mark
Dorset Mark - 19 Jul 2004 20:50 GMT
PS I have the photos to prove that you'll have a good time see the
link..............  http://tinyurl.com/3kuud

--
Dorset Mark
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.