Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
ArticlesDiving DestinationsLearning Scuba DivingMarine LifeMiscellaneous
Discussion GroupsGeneralScuba EquipmentScuba LocationsAustralian ScubaUK Scuba
DirectoryScuba Clubs

Scuba Forum / Scuba Locations / September 2004

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

San Diego Shark Diving - Great Whites

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Gary - 16 Sep 2004 22:04 GMT
I live in Chicago and recently signed up for a great white trip to
Guadalupe Island. Has anyone made this trip? How often do they see
sharks and what kind of camera should I bring? Any info will be
helpful thanks
lance smith - 18 Sep 2004 08:31 GMT
> I live in Chicago and recently signed up for a great white trip to
> Guadalupe Island. Has anyone made this trip? How often do they see
> sharks

Who are you signed up with?

> and what kind of camera should I bring?

An underwater camera : ) If it's the type of dive trip that requires a
plane ride it's not the type of dive trip you want to be experimenting
and practicing with a new camera (or any other fancy gear). What
camera have you been using so far? Take that one.

> Any info will be helpful thanks

The vis is great and the water warm right now. Both in the 70's.

-lance smith
Gary - 18 Sep 2004 15:26 GMT
> I live in Chicago and recently signed up for a great white trip to
> Guadalupe Island. Has anyone made this trip? How often do they see
> sharks and what kind of camera should I bring? Any info will be
> helpful thanks.

I signed up with Underseas Scuba in Addison, IL.
lance smith - 18 Sep 2004 23:13 GMT
> > I live in Chicago and recently signed up for a great white trip to
> > Guadalupe Island. Has anyone made this trip? How often do they see
> > sharks and what kind of camera should I bring? Any info will be
> > helpful thanks.
>
> I signed up with Underseas Scuba in Addison, IL.

Small world! I was on board with Sandy H. in Belize a couple of years
ago! Do you know which operator they will be diving with? I am
assuming you are departing out of San Diego with Horizon Charters?

I'm 95% sure you will be with Horizon, be sure to reserve your bunk
ahead of time if possible. The Horizon has nice bunks, but the 'rooms'
are much nicer and offer more privacy. If you have to get a bunk get
the middle or the top bunk, they're stacked 3-up. Their skippers,
you'll get Ron or Greg, they're both good and run a tight ship. The
food is decent, remember to get the Mango Madness after your dives are
done for the day!

Other info: you can wear wet-wet suits in the galley. I suggest bring
some water bottles, etc on board. You can buy them from the boat of
course (i'm assuming they are not included in the price- they're not
for 1-2 day trips). Bring a pillow too. I usually bring a 30F sleeping
bag for the Horizon.

Here's some recent info from the Horizon crew:
http://www.horizoncharters.com/log.html

As for the camera keep using what you're using. If you haven't been
diving with one get something cheap. Cannon A75 or something with the
scuba housing.

-lance smith
Gary - 20 Sep 2004 16:26 GMT
> > > I live in Chicago and recently signed up for a great white trip to
> > > Guadalupe Island. Has anyone made this trip? How often do they see
[quoted text clipped - 29 lines]
>
> -lance smith

Yep...the chater operator is Horizon. Bruce made the trip last year
and they saw at least 1 shark EACH time they had divers in the water.
He has video of one time there were 5 great whites circling the cages!
Thanks for the tips about the boat and crew. My concern with the
camera was whether my 20mm lens  was wide angle enough. I've had
little experience tying to photo animals 15 feet long.
lance smith - 20 Sep 2004 23:01 GMT
> Yep...the chater operator is Horizon. Bruce made the trip last year
> and they saw at least 1 shark EACH time they had divers in the water.
> He has video of one time there were 5 great whites circling the cages!
> Thanks for the tips about the boat and crew. My concern with the
> camera was whether my 20mm lens  was wide angle enough. I've had
> little experience tying to photo animals 15 feet long.

Hmmm... I'm not sure what's best for your lens situation. But you
won't have a problem if they're headed straight for you : )

-lance smith
Ramone Cila - 21 Sep 2004 18:50 GMT
> > Yep...the chater operator is Horizon. Bruce made the trip last year
> > and they saw at least 1 shark EACH time they had divers in the water.
[quoted text clipped - 7 lines]
>
> -lance smith

I made that trip with Doc last October. We had multiple sharks everyday,
from the moment the cages were dropped until the moment they were hoisted.
We had sharks from 8 feet to 20 feet, though most of them were 12 to 14
feet.

On Horizon, the way Doc works it, you can have a number of camera setups
ready to go. You label each rig with "Gary 15" or "Gary 20" or "Gary 20-35"
and whenever you want to change you poke your head out of the cage, yell out
"Gary whatever" and they will retrieve the rig you desire. Having said that
though, I think a 20 is a better overall choice than the 15 **if you will
only have one camera setup** and the 20-35 is even better than that. I
wouldn't shoot any prime lens with a smaller perspective than 20mm though.
The sharks get close, we had a couple that were rather insistent on bumping
the cages, but most stayed 2 to 3 feet away on their close passes.

From the outside corner spots on the cages you can capture the whole animal
(plus sufficient background) as it approaches the bait lines with a 20. Also
when they come right up to the cage a 20 or 15 will work nicely. As they
swim under, around, away and whatever, you are still talking at least 20
before the water column deteriorates the image anyway.

It's a great trip, I hope to return again some day. Food onboard was
excellent, I mean really quite good. I'm not a drinker but was told the
concoctions were delicious. Accomodations are really bunkboat rather than
liveaboard, but for a 5 day cruise it hardly matters. There's lot's of
fishing to do in between your cage turns and the weather down there at that
time of year is really nice.

The sole downside to the trip was the crossing back to SD. Ours was as rough
as anything I have ever been on, far worse than my worse Coco crossing, and
lasted for a good 18 hours before the seas settled. Even if you don't get
sick you still cannot find anything to do to pass the time in the rollin'
rockin' Horizon....reading, chess, cards, they are all out of the question
because that little boat is pretty active in a heavy sea. So be prepared to
weather that crossing if indeed the seas do not cooperate on your tour.

I started the "dives" in a 5 mil with hooded 2 mil vest and eventually ended
up "diving" with just the 5 mil. The water is somewhat cold, but I
acclimated quickly and found more comfort in less neoprene. Some folks dove
dry, but I had been advised it wasn't necessary and found that to be true.

You probably will anyway, but just as a point of unsolicited advice: Pay
attention to their system for entering and exiting the cages, it works
nicely, is safe, and is the fastest way for the exchange from one group to
the next. We had one guy who thought he would do it his way and came *that*
close to losing his balance and falling off the cage into the water with 3
Great White just a few feet away. A 20 would have worked nicely for that
photo op as well! :^)

Have a great time. I am decidedly envious!
Dillon Pyron - 21 Sep 2004 22:11 GMT
>You probably will anyway, but just as a point of unsolicited advice: Pay
>attention to their system for entering and exiting the cages, it works
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>Great White just a few feet away. A 20 would have worked nicely for that
>photo op as well! :^)

What color filter works best for red water?  :-)

>Have a great time. I am decidedly envious!

Signature

dillon

When I was a kid, I thought the angel's name was Hark
and the horse's name was Bob.

Gary - 24 Sep 2004 01:20 GMT
> > garygigfy@aol.com (Gary) wrote in message
>  news:<e954d5a8.0409200726.2459986f@posting.google.com>...
[quoted text clipped - 61 lines]
>
> Have a great time. I am decidedly envious!

Thanks for the great advice!. I am now much more comfortable with just
my 20. I too have heard that the sharks get very close and can damage
photo equipment if your not careful.

I've made plenty of rough crossings in bunks, so I know i'll be
uncomfortable. But I'm sure it'll be worth it if the "big boys" are
around. Nice to hear that the food will be good!

If you're truely envious sign up for the trip. Bruce says he has 2 or
three openings and the remai,ing trips are all sold out ( i guess word
is spreading about this trip). Maybe I'll see you on board.
Ramone Cila - 24 Sep 2004 19:36 GMT
> Thanks for the great advice!. I am now much more comfortable with just
> my 20. I too have heard that the sharks get very close and can damage
> photo equipment if your not careful.

You're welcome for whatever help my advice brings. As far as sharks getting
close you have to know this: to make good images, given the cages and
proximity of other photogs, you HAVE to lean well outside the cage.....head,
arms, cameras, strobes and shoulders....to repeatedly get shots without
someones elses strobes and arms in your shot. And if the guy next to you
leans out you have to lean out farther. I was hesitant at first to lean to
far out, but quickly realized that without doing so my shots were going to
be ruined by the inclusion of my neighbor's gear. It's unfortunate but
shooting wide angle in a tight space is the perfect recipe for all kinds of
things ending up in your shot. By my third turn in the cage I was out of
the cage up to my chest trying to get clean shots. I did :^)

> I've made plenty of rough crossings in bunks, so I know I'll be
> uncomfortable. But I'm sure it'll be worth it if the "big boys" are
> around.

I have as well, but this crossing heading back to SD is a trip, and the boat
while sound is the lest comfortable craft I have ever made a crossing in. It
bobs, rolls, rocks and dips. But it gets you to an amazing experience.

> Nice to hear that the food will be good!

It was no small surprise to me, but apparently the cook has a great
reputation amongst California divers and fishermen. Well earned I might add.
He doesn't have a state of the art galley to work from either. You know, I
cannot remember his name...maybe Greg. Anyone here that can help with his
name?

> If you're truely envious sign up for the trip. Bruce says he has 2 or
> three openings and the remai,ing trips are all sold out ( i guess word
> is spreading about this trip). Maybe I'll see you on board.

Not this time. I have Lembah Strait, Wakatobi and Galapagos coming up
between now and April. My wife would kill me if I popped up with another
trip  Ha ha haaa! But yeah, I am envious. Guadalupe is an extraordinary way
to visit with Great Whites. Far better than any other Great White trip I
have done in other parts of the world. The viz, the number of animals and
the reliability of sightings. It's unlike any place else on earth that
divers know about right now. Sometimes the viz is too good, leaving a
mottled look on the shark's back from the sun. And man, if that's the
complaint you know it's a good experience :^)
Greg Mossman - 24 Sep 2004 23:18 GMT
> It was no small surprise to me, but apparently the cook has a great
> reputation amongst California divers and fishermen. Well earned I might
> add.
> He doesn't have a state of the art galley to work from either. You know, I
> cannot remember his name...maybe Greg. Anyone here that can help with his
> name?

Mark.  Greg is the captain (and owner's son).

> Not this time. I have Lembah Strait, Wakatobi and Galapagos coming up
> between now and April. My wife would kill me if I popped up with another
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> mottled look on the shark's back from the sun. And man, if that's the
> complaint you know it's a good experience :^)

My complaint is that the Horizon used to run a summerful of Baja dive trips
for real divers (free and SCUBA), but is now mainly taken up by
photographers who want to sit in a cage the entire time.  They still do a
handful of non-sharkcage trips, but only four this year according to their
schedule and they're the only game in town for that sort of thing.
Ramone Cila - 25 Sep 2004 00:34 GMT
> > It was no small surprise to me, but apparently the cook has a great
> > reputation amongst California divers and fishermen. Well earned I might
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>
> Mark.  Greg is the captain (and owner's son).

Yesiree...Mark. Thanks.

When I was onboard the Captain was the owner's daughter. Again, I don't
remember her name. Strong looking girl though.

> > Not this time. I have Lembah Strait, Wakatobi and Galapagos coming up
> > between now and April. My wife would kill me if I popped up with another
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> for real divers (free and SCUBA), but is now mainly taken up by
> photographers who want to sit in a cage the entire time.

Ah, I think most photographers are "real" divers. They are just people for
whom the diving has become a means to a photographic end. But I have seen
over the past 10 years or so that this mismatched intent has given way to
some animosity between the two groups. Generally I don't want sightseers
around when I am shooting and sightseers don't want me around shooting when
they are trying to discover. I think there is a shared responsibility to
avoid one and other if at all possible :^)

> Plus most would rather dive with the sharks than sit in a cage.

Me too. I find it strange that all Doc's shark dives are in cages. The
Whities I understand, but some of the other dives can be done outside of
cages. To each his own, but for sharks I enjoy being in the water with them.
Though on the whole I can think of far more interesting dives than those
dedicated to most sharks.

> They still do a
> handful of non-sharkcage trips, but only four this year according to their
> schedule and they're the only game in town for that sort of thing.

That's what they told me when I was onboard. I guess they also did quite a
bit of fishing trips as well, but I think the sharkdiving charters with Doc
Ames is easier on the boat, crew and budget.
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.