> >> Well, it's clear to me why there are some Canadians that are
> >> against guns. They all got knives, and they know how to use them.
> >> Guess they will ban them next. Wonder if this guy's wife would
> >> be more dead if he shot her--once. Dan
http://the.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/2007/Mar/01/br/br9416507238.html
> > It doesn't describe the knife, but its quite likely that the knife was not
> > designed to kill, particularly since it tookl 100 tries.
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
>
> seems fair enough.
And here we disagree.
To me, generally, Its what a person actually does with the item, and not
"what it was designed to do". And i that action is criminal, then they'll
face the consequences.
A person killed by a knife, a baseball bat, or a car is just as dead as one
killed by a gun. Presuming that the killing was not jsutified as
self-defense (or other legal grounds), then that person, that person, should
be the one punished. Not all the folks who'll peacably carve meat (long
kitchen knives), hit balls, or drive to work. And, naturally, it includes
those who'll either hunt or target shoot with the weapon of their choice.
Yes, there are folks who hunt here with pistols.
Dennis
dechucka - 03 Mar 2007 22:07 GMT
>> >> Well, it's clear to me why there are some Canadians that are
>> >> against guns. They all got knives, and they know how to use them.
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
>
> And here we disagree.
sure do
> To me, generally, Its what a person actually does with the item, and not
> "what it was designed to do". And i that action is criminal, then they'll
> face the consequences.
exactly
> A person killed by a knife, a baseball bat, or a car is just as dead as
> one
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> those who'll either hunt or target shoot with the weapon of their choice.
> Yes, there are folks who hunt here with pistols.
sorry what was the accidental death and injury rate in the US last year, the
murder rate?
As I said I am happy enough with our gun laws you are happy with yours so we
will have to disagree
Dennis (Icarus) - 04 Mar 2007 03:07 GMT
> >> >> Well, it's clear to me why there are some Canadians that are
> >> >> against guns. They all got knives, and they know how to use them.
> >> >> Guess they will ban them next. Wonder if this guy's wife would
> >> >> be more dead if he shot her--once. Dan
http://the.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/2007/Mar/01/br/br9416507238.html
> >> > It doesn't describe the knife, but its quite likely that the knife was
> > not
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
>
> exactly
Oh? Then why excuse stuff "based on its intended purpose"?
Why punish everyone, for the bad behaviour of a few?
> > A person killed by a knife, a baseball bat, or a car is just as dead as
> > one
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> sorry what was the accidental death and injury rate in the US last year, the
> murder rate?
As Doug pointed out, our non-gun voilent crime is 3x higher than Japan's.
And, as was pointed out, one country IIRC Germany, experienced a
near-doubling
of violent crime after banning firearms.
> As I said I am happy enough with our gun laws you are happy with yours so we
> will have to disagree
Yes, we will.
Dennis