Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
ArticlesDiving DestinationsLearning Scuba DivingMarine LifeMiscellaneous
Discussion GroupsGeneralScuba EquipmentScuba LocationsAustralian ScubaUK Scuba
DirectoryScuba Clubs

Scuba Forum / General / July 2006

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Bubble Grade Study in Actual Scuba Diving Conditions

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
mike gray - 12 Jul 2006 04:33 GMT
posted by Ern Campbell, MD, on 10footstop

(for you newbies, 10footstop is the only diving medical source
worth a sh.t, and a {free} subscription is mandatory for all
divers that have even the slightest interest in their health.)

June 2, 2006 — An echocardiographic study done on healthy
volunteers in actual scuba diving conditions found an important
bubble grade in all, according to a report in the May issue of
Chest [Chest. 2006;129:1337-1343]. The hemodynamic changes
suggested that hypovolemia [low blood volume] is an important
factor and that restoration of fluid balance should be
considered after all dives.

"During a scuba dive, subjects undergo environmental constraints
such as immersion, exposure to cold, and increased ambient
pressure," write Alain Boussuges, MD, PhD, from the Institut de
Médecine Navale du Service de Santé des Armées in Marseille,
France, and colleagues. "Intravascular gas bubbles are carried
from the venous circulation to the pulmonary vessel, where they
are eliminated through the lungs. The formation of bubbles is
recognized as the basis for decompression illness, but such
bubbles are also commonly detected in venous circulation of
asymptomatic divers."

Ten divers were studied and one hour after the dive,
microbubbles were detected in the right-heart chambers of all
subjects, and left atrial and left ventricular diameters were
significantly decreased. Cardiac output measured by aortic blood
flow remained unchanged, but heart rate increased and stroke
volume decreased after the dive. Left ventricular filling, which
was assessed on transmitral profile, was partially increased by
atrial contraction. Right cavity diameters were unchanged, but
there was an increase of the right ventricular/right atrial
gradient pressure.

"The diving profile studied promotes a rather important bubble
grade in all volunteers," the authors write. "Two factors can
explain these results: low volemia secondary to immersion, and
venous gas embolism induced by nitrogen desaturation.
Consequently, restoration of the water balance of the body
should be considered in the recovery process after diving."

Clinical Context
Scuba diving invilves immersion in water and the use of
self-contained breathing units known to produce some interesting
effects on the circulation, including a reduction in peripheral
blood flow that concentrates blood in the central circulation.
This effect, in turn, stimulates increased release of atrial
natriuretic peptide and diuresis. In addition, the increase in
ambient pressure associated with diving increases the arterial
concentrations of oxygen and nitrogen, and the higher levels of
oxygen may impair cardiac relaxation.

Previous studies have suggested possible cardiac changes
associated with scuba diving. The current study follows up 10
healthy male volunteers with echocardiography before and after
diving to document these changes.

Study Highlights
*Study subjects underwent echocardiography at baseline and 1
hour following a 25-minute dive at a mean depth of 34.3 m.
Participants breathed a standard mixture of nitrogen and oxygen
and wore neoprene diving suits.
*Circulating bubbles following the dive were detected with 2-D
echography.
*The main study outcomes were differences in echocardiogram data
before and after the experimental dive.
*All participants had evidence of circulating bubbles, and 7 of
the 10 divers had grade 3 bubbles (the majority of cardiac
periods contained bubble signals singularly or in group).
*The authors conclude that a relative hypovolemia and venous gas
embolism help explain the changes in echocardiographic findings
following diving, and they recommend oral rehydration following
diving. Rehydration might be especially important in the setting
of repeated diving.

Take home stuff:
Scuba diving can reduce peripheral blood flow, increase the
release of atrial natriuretic peptide and diuresis, and increase
the arterial partial pressures of oxygen and nitrogen.
The current study suggests that oral rehydration following
recreational scuba diving may reduce echocardiographic changes
associated with diving.
-hh - 12 Jul 2006 12:13 GMT
> posted by Ern Campbell, MD, on 10footstop
>
> (for you newbies, 10footstop is the only diving medical source
> worth a sh.t, and a {free} subscription is mandatory for all
> divers that have even the slightest interest in their health.)

Absolutely.

> Study Highlights
> *Study subjects underwent echocardiography at baseline and 1
> hour following a 25-minute dive at a mean depth of 34.3 m.

34m = 112ft, although its not clear if this is fsw or ffw.

In any event, that ~3% difference would still suggest using 110fsw on a
generic dive table, and as per the old (ie "60ft for 60min") USN Dive
Tables, this profile of 25 minutes @ 110fsw would have called for a 3
minute (True) Decompression Stop at 10fsw.  More modern tables would
have called for even longer stops.

It is unclear if their dive protocol included a 3 minute 'safety' stop
or not.

In any event, if it did, then the results would fairly faithfully
represent the level of bubbles that were present within what used to be
the accepted standard.  If not, then it exceeded this old standard
(relatively slightly).

> *All participants had evidence of circulating bubbles, and 7 of
> the 10 divers had grade 3 bubbles (the majority of cardiac
> periods contained bubble signals singularly or in group).

Definitions:

Grade 0 = no detectable bubbles
Grade 1 = an occasional bubble, with most cardiac cycles free
Grade 2 = many, but less than half, of the cycles contain bubbles
Grade 3 = most cardiac cycles contain bubbles
Grade 4 = severe bubbling which obscures the cardiac signal

General Interpretation:

With grade 0 bubbles, there is little chance of DCS; with grades 1 and
2 there is moderate risk.  The risk of DCS is greatest when grade 3 or
4 bubbling is present.

(from: http://www.brooks.af.mil/af/files/fsguide/HTML/Chapter_03.html )

And with 70% of the test subjects manifesting bubbles in excess of
Grade 2, let's take a moment to pause and thank the volunteers who
agreed to be exposed in this test.

> Take home stuff:
> Scuba diving can reduce peripheral blood flow, increase the
> release of atrial natriuretic peptide and diuresis, and increase
> the arterial partial pressures of oxygen and nitrogen.

> The current study suggests that oral rehydration following
                                 ^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^
> recreational scuba diving may reduce echocardiographic changes
> associated with diving.

Plus before the dive, too.  Think of this as YA scientific study that
shows why its good for you to need to pee in your wetsuit.

-hh
mike gray - 12 Jul 2006 14:34 GMT
>>posted by Ern Campbell, MD, on 10footstop

(snip)

Did you send these comments to Campbell?
Dave C - 12 Jul 2006 14:45 GMT
> > posted by Ern Campbell, MD, on 10footstop
> >
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>
> Absolutely.

Thank you Mike and Hugh for excellent posts!

The link to free subscription for 10footstop:

http://mail.scuba-doc.com/mailman/listinfo/10footstop_scuba-doc.com

snip

> General Interpretation:
>
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>
> (from: http://www.brooks.af.mil/af/files/fsguide/HTML/Chapter_03.html )

Good food for thought. I'll try to find out what "moderate risk" means,
though.

> And with 70% of the test subjects manifesting bubbles in excess of
> Grade 2, let's take a moment to pause and thank the volunteers who
> agreed to be exposed in this test.

Depending on what they mean by "moderate risk", I might like to
participate in a such a study.

> > Take home stuff:
> > Scuba diving can reduce peripheral blood flow, increase the
> > release of atrial natriuretic peptide and diuresis, and increase
> > the arterial partial pressures of oxygen and nitrogen.

In the exerpt, the study's authors did not comment on which factors in
scuba diving caused the reduced peripheral blood flow. I think
peripheral vasoconstriction due to cooling would be the prime factor,
which would imply that, compared to wetsuit diving, drysuit diving
would have less dehydration and therefore less concentration of
bubbles.

If so, I can use this as a good argument for the degree to which I try
to avoid being cold by wearing more undergarments, using double socks
and drygloves, ice cap, etc., even in water up to 60 degrees. "I'm
_not_ a wuss, I'm reducing my chance of bubble illness!"   8^)

I've found that my added warmth has meant I can spend long periods (up
to 4 hours over a couple of dives) in sub-50 degree water without
reaching a point of bladder pain, so I would assume I'm remaining
better hydrated. I may have a little increased sweat in the
undergarments, but that doesn't seem like a big factor in my low
exertion dives.

> > The current study suggests that oral rehydration following
>                                   ^^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^
> > recreational scuba diving may reduce echocardiographic changes
> > associated with diving.

> Plus before the dive, too.  Think of this as YA scientific study that
> shows why its good for you to need to pee in your wetsuit.

Good point about the benefit of overhydration.

Dave C

PURE TALC: Source, supplier of unscented, oil-free, USP grade PURE
TALC, ideal for use on drysuit latex seals. If interested, please see
my talc offerings on eBay (eBay ID: dave4868). Thank you!
Alan Street - 12 Jul 2006 19:11 GMT
> > > posted by Ern Campbell, MD, on 10footstop
> > >
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>
> http://mail.scuba-doc.com/mailman/listinfo/10footstop_scuba-doc.com

Thanks, Dave.

Alan
Dillon Pyron - 14 Jul 2006 03:13 GMT
>> posted by Ern Campbell, MD, on 10footstop
>>
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>
>34m = 112ft, although its not clear if this is fsw or ffw.

If you're using a gauge, it really doesn't matter.  All a gauge does
is convert pound/grams per square inch/centimeter into feet/meters.
Since it's all about pressure, it doesn't matter.  Now, if you're
hanging out on a rope 15 feet below the ship, it is going to count for
something..

I remember being on the hard bottom at Black Rock on Maui and
listening to the ascent alarm going off as the surf passed over head.
Bother us enough to head for deeper water.
Signature

dillon

JAFO

Okidiver - 13 Jul 2006 00:39 GMT
"Clinical Context
Scuba diving invilves immersion in water "

Also forgot to run the spell checker... wonder what else they forgot?
College graduates, geez...
Signature

Rapid Rick
"Just Nit Pick, Baby"

 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.