Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
ArticlesDiving DestinationsLearning Scuba DivingMarine LifeMiscellaneous
Discussion GroupsGeneralScuba EquipmentScuba LocationsAustralian ScubaUK Scuba
DirectoryScuba Clubs

Scuba Forum / General / June 2006

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Divers Request EPA Intervention...

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
mike gray - 08 Jun 2006 00:08 GMT
Delray  Beach, Florida – June 7, 2006

Divers Request EPA Intervention to Save Threatened Corals from
Sewage

Controversy  surrounding the dumping of partially treated sewage
onto a popular coral reef in  Delray Beach, Florida, reached a
new level this week when a group of scuba  divers made a formal
request for the federal EPA to intervene and help save
threatened corals, recently added to the Endangered Species
List.  The group, Palm Beach County Reef  Rescue, has been
fighting to save their local coral reefs from algae blooms
since March 2002.
The problem; nutrient  pollutants in the sewage feed algae,
which smother and kill the coral, according  to Reef Rescue’s
director, Ed Tichenor.
The latest chain of  events began May 5, when the National
Oceanographic and Atmospheric  Administration, NOAA announced
its decision to list  Elkhorn and Staghorn corals as threatened
under the Endangered Species Act.  According to NOAA, the
determination was made because these corals  are likely to
become in danger of extinction throughout all or a portion of
their range in the foreseeable future.  "This is the first time
coral species have been listed as threatened in  the United
States," said Assistant Administrator for the NOAA
Fisheries Service,  Bill Hogarth.
Reef Rescue filed their EPA request  for intervention under rule
7 of the Endangered Species Act, which requires  federal
agencies to take action 30 days after the listing to ensure
that they are not permitting activities likely to
jeopardize the continued  existence of the threatened species.
“The Delray/Boynton sewer plant must have a NPDES permit to
discharge  into the ocean and under the federal Clean Water Act
the EPA has ultimate  oversight responsibility”, Tichenor said.
The  sewer plant has been operating without a valid discharge
permit since it expired  December 2005.  The state of Florida
has rejected the plant’s permit renewal application five times
within the last  year as incomplete for failing to adequately
address DEP requests for additional  information.
Reef Rescue hopes involvement by the  federal agency will break
the impasse between the sewer plant and the Florida  DEP and
force the plant to comply with all requirements of the Clean
Water Act.  The most basic tenet of which is that the discharged
sewage must not degrade the  receiving environment, in this
case, a threatened coral reef  habitat.

Interview contact: Ed Tichenor,  Director
Palm Beach County Reef Rescue
Telephone: (561) 699-8559
Email:  etichscuba@aol.com

Palm Beach County Reef Rescue
PO Box 207
Boynton  Beach, Florida 33425
Web site: www.reef-rescue.org

Additional media  resources:
Elkhorn  and Staghorn Coral Information:
http://sero.nmfs.noaa.gov/pr/protres.htm
Staghorn  Coral (Acropora cervicornis) Image:
http://sero.nmfs.noaa.gov/pr/docs/05.jpg
Still photography - Delray  outfall: Steve Spring (202)
255-3113, email:
SS2PB@aol.com
Video - Delray outfall &  algae bloom: Elaine Blum (561)
523-7061, email:  divereb@adelphia.net

.............................................................

Note: In fact, there has been very little support for this
effort from divers, even those using these reefs. I believe
that, of the people on this newsgroup, only two have helped Ed
and Reef Rescue in this long and expensive project to save the
Boynton reefs (the other one may not want to be identified, but
his name rhymes with sick rims).

Non-financial supporters of Reef Rescue include the state of
Florida, Palm Beach County, the Sierra Club, several local dive
operators and shops, NOAA, and several other very legitimate
organizations.

But the cost of the effort has been largely out of Ed Tichenor's
pocket, and his pocket is not very deep.

You can help this project that is actually making a real impact
that can benefit us divers. Send Reef Rescue a check! Go buy
some stuff from the website. This project is nearing success,
don't let it die because yer to cheap to send Reef Rescue a
couple bucks!

mike gray
George Price - 12 Jun 2006 05:49 GMT
> Delray  Beach, Florida – June 7, 2006
>
[quoted text clipped - 65 lines]
> expensive project to save the Boynton reefs (the other one may not want to
> be identified, but his name rhymes with sick rims).

Yes , but I think he needs to keep up the pressure.  There are a lot of us
that have
signed the petition. Maybe, we need to reminded, as he does in my email,
that this is an ongoing
problem that needs to be dealt with to get some resolution to the matter.  I
think the main factor
is that they (the sewage people) never put it as deep and off shore as it
was supposed to be.
I beleive that to be the crux o f the matter.  Am I right about that?

The last video I saw was quite distressing, watching all of these fish
feeding off the effulent of this sh.t tube.
I pity the poor f's that get sick from fish caught from feeding on the sh.t 
effulent.  Unfortuately, maybe once
they start showing up in the hospital, it will hit home, and get the
attention of the brain dead, politically motivated
POS that are behind the beauracratic quagmire Ed has been up againt.
Hopefully, nobody dies as a result.

George

> Non-financial supporters of Reef Rescue include the state of Florida, Palm
> Beach County, the Sierra Club, several local dive operators and shops,
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>
> mike gray
Al Wells - 12 Jun 2006 10:59 GMT
> Yes , but I think he needs to keep up the pressure.  There are a lot of us
> that have
> signed the petition. Maybe, we need to reminded, as he does in my email,
> that this is an ongoing
> problem that needs to be dealt with to get some resolution to the matter.

signing the petition is good, but the bottom line is that there are
considerable expenses involved in this, and he needs some help with
them. I bought some T shirts earlier, but after Mike's message decided
to also contribute some money. This is what is needed. Ed's science is
solid. This can be won if we help him to keep up the pressure.
George Price - 15 Jun 2006 06:05 GMT
>> Yes , but I think he needs to keep up the pressure.  There are a lot of
>> us
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
> to also contribute some money. This is what is needed. Ed's science is
> solid. This can be won if we help him to keep up the pressure.

To use HH's euphemism;  agreed.

The science is well done, and hard to ignore.  That is the sticking point.
How long
can the political forces override the obvious problem?  Depending on the
players,
their affiliations, etc. it could go either way.

Point well taken.  Throwing some financial support at it seems to be a more
appropriate
response to keep Ed supported in more than words.

George
Lee Bell - 15 Jun 2006 11:58 GMT
> Throwing some financial support at it seems to be a more appropriate
> response to keep Ed supported in more than words.

There's no question that financial support is appropriate, but to get
politicians to move, you need more than money.  You need a show of personal
support from the community.  You need to show them numbers of people
sufficiently dedicated to improvement to actually do something about it
themselves.

Today is a day we can show such support.  There's a meeting to discuss the
problem of anchoring on the same reefs being impacted by the sewage outfall
at 2:00 PM today at the FWC offices in West Palm Beach.  I will be there.
Who else thinks this is worth the time it takes to make your voice heard in
person?

Lee
mike gray - 15 Jun 2006 14:11 GMT
>>Throwing some financial support at it seems to be a more appropriate
>>response to keep Ed supported in more than words.
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> Who else thinks this is worth the time it takes to make your voice heard in
> person?

Yeah, I'll go with ya. Wanna ride up together?

But George is right about the money. The laws exist to remedy
the problem, but are unenforced because of enforcement budgets.
What Reef Rescue needs, in my opinion, is legal help - expensive
legal help - to force the authorities to enforce the laws
against anchoring in the reef, against dumping sewage on the
reef, against turbidity levels from beach renourishment
projects, etc etc etc.

All our whining and pissing and moaning is nice, and makes us
feel good, but we've got to work the system to GET EXISTING LAWS
ENFORCED, and that takes money.

m
Lee Bell - 15 Jun 2006 15:19 GMT
> Yeah, I'll go with ya. Wanna ride up together?

Yep.  I was going to call you in a few minutes anyway.  Do you think Deborah
would like to/could go with us as well?  How about Bulshark?  If I'm going
to drive all the way up there, I might as well take as many as I can with
me.

> But George is right about the money. The laws exist to remedy the problem,
> but are unenforced because of enforcement budgets.

I'd damned sure rather spend our tax dollars protecting the reefs than on
enforceing now wake zones for Manatees.  I kind of agree on the reason for
the lack of enforcement, but I think it's more whose money is available for
what than how much.  The rich and famous aren't real active on this issue.
Where's Jimmy Buffet when we need him?

> What Reef Rescue needs, in my opinion, is legal help - expensive legal
> help - to force the authorities to enforce the laws against anchoring in
> the reef, against dumping sewage on the reef, against turbidity levels
> from beach renourishment projects, etc etc etc.

Or perhaps just some public officials willing to do their jobs in the face
of heavy lobbying not to.  Let's face it, we're fighting city hall on this
one.  Neither Delray nor any of the other coastal towns have a lot of
incentive to put the welfare of the reefs ahead ofhte welfare of their
tourist beaches.

> All our whining and pissing and moaning is nice, and makes us feel good,
> but we've got to work the system to GET EXISTING LAWS ENFORCED, and that
> takes money.

Let's use the money we've been paying to enforcement agencies that aren't
enforcing the laws.

Mike, I've got a copy of the FWC enforcement booklet and have been looking
other places for the laws prohibiting anchoring on coral reefs other than
those in the parks.  Do you happen to have a link that will save me time it
takes to look?

Lee
Rick Simms - 16 Jun 2006 16:29 GMT
>> Throwing some financial support at it seems to be a more appropriate
>> response to keep Ed supported in more than words.
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
>Lee

Got an address and a contact name that a concerned transient diver can
send a letter expressing his disapproval?

Rick Simms
**************************************  
"Success isn't always permanent and failure isn't always fatal."
mike gray - 16 Jun 2006 20:00 GMT
>>>Throwing some financial support at it seems to be a more appropriate
>>>response to keep Ed supported in more than words.
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
> **************************************  
> "Success isn't always permanent and failure isn't always fatal."

I was at the meeting, about 8 citizens and 20 state officials.
The meeting was very positive and productive, and the various
state agencies (including the state's legal counsel) appear to
be unanimous that laws and regulations need to be changed to
prevent anchoring in the reef and provide serious enforcement.

There appears to be support for long term establishment of
"no-anchor" zones, with potential enforcement support from the
feds, as in the Keys.

Near term (a year), there will be some education for boaters on
the harm this does, and some changes in regulations that will
allow some (weak) enforcement.

Ed Tichenor is drafting a letter, with input from several
others, and a sample with recipients will be posted here soon.

Thanks for your continuing support.

m
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.