Scuba Forum / General / May 2004
Diver Rescued by Boy Scouts
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Popeye NCAT3 - 29 Apr 2004 15:19 GMT Man Was Adrift After Boat Crew Forgot Him
NEWPORT BEACH, Calif. (April 29) - A recreational diver forgotten at sea by a boat crew drifted five hours and prayed for his life before a Boy Scout on an excursion aboard a century-old ship spotted him.
Dan Carlock, 45, was left by his diving group Sunday as he drifted for hours about seven miles offshore. He noted the time of day on his small, waterproof writing slate and took photographs of himself to document that he'd made it to the surface.
Carlock, a former Boy Scout, recalled his survival manual: Stay calm. Think methodically. Still, he worried about how his parents would react to his death.
He said he prayed "God, I don't want to die," and "I want to be saved. I need your help."
The spacecraft engineer for Boeing Satellite Systems and three dive buddies entered the water at about 8:45 a.m. Sunday, but Carlock had problems equalizing the pressure in his ears and he fell behind. He tried following his partners' bubbles, but he lost them.
He decided to end the dive after 15 minutes, but he was 400 feet down current from an oil platform where the boat was anchored. He blew his whistle to attract attention.
"I figured when the dive was over they would realize I was missing and come looking for me," Carlock said.
But they never came. The boat left and headed for a shipwreck six miles southeast of the entrance to the Port of Los Angeles, said Coast Guard Petty Officer Collin Croft.
Five hours later, crew trainee Zack Mayberry, 15, stood watch on the stern of the tall ship Argus, which was full of Boy Scouts. The ship had changed course because of heavy fog.
Mayberry saw something in the water and grabbed his binoculars: About 150 yards away, Carlock's head was sticking out of the water. Mayberry handed the binoculars to a friend.
"I wanted to make sure my eyes weren't playing tricks on me," Mayberry said.
The San Diego Boy Scout troop had drilled the rescue procedure the previous day and the rescue operation began. A small motorboat was sent to pluck Carlock from the sea and he was brought aboard.
Coast Guard officials Tuesday said they were investigating why Carlock was left behind, then not reported missing until his group reached the second dive location at 12:03 p.m.
The Coast Guard, the recreational diving instructors, Long Beach lifeguards and Los Angeles City Fire Department personnel searched for Carlock near the second dive location until learning of the rescue.
Ocean Adventures Dive Co. owner Steve Ladd said he was trying to figure out what happened.
Popeye The Power! \ /
Greg Mossman - 29 Apr 2004 17:34 GMT > Man Was Adrift After Boat Crew Forgot Him This version has a bit more detail:
(I was just talking to a buddy about giving the Sundiver a try the next time we went out - now I think not)
By BRIAN MARTINEZ The Orange County Register A feeling of powerlessness slowly swept over Dan Carlock as he drifted in the ocean for nearly five hours Sunday, seven miles from Newport Harbor. There were no signs of his scuba-diving group.
Four times, he noted the time of day on his small, waterproof writing slate and took photographs of himself to document that he'd made it to the surface and how long he had lasted at sea.
He worried about how his parents would react to his death. But he never lost hope.
"God, I don't want to die," he prayed, breaking down in tears. "I want to be saved. I need your help."
Carlock, 45, thought of a survival manual he read as a Boy Scout. Stay calm. Think methodically through the situation. He turned his head and feet east, toward land and away from where he last saw his companions.
Aboard the century-old tall ship Argus, crew trainee Zack Mayberry, 15, stood watch on the stern. The ship full of Boy Scouts was returning to Newport Beach from Santa Catalina Island and two hours earlier had to change its course because of heavy fog.
Mayberry thought he noticed a balloon or debris floating in the sea. He grabbed his binoculars to take a closer look. About 150 yards away, Carlock's head was sticking out of the water, and he was waving a bright, yellow-green tube.
Mayberry handed the binoculars to a friend.
"I wanted to make sure my eyes weren't playing tricks on me," Mayberry said.
The friend confirmed it.
"Man overboard!" they yelled.
Carlock belted out a joyful "Yeah!" as he pumped his fists in excitement.
The Boy Scout troop from San Diego had drilled the rescue procedure just a day before, and this time it went like clockwork, First Mate Al Sorkin said. The crew quickly sent out a small motorboat to bring Carlock aboard.
The Scouts gave Carlock warm clothes, a sandwich and hot coffee.
Tuesday, Coast Guard officials were investigating why Carlock was found 11 miles from the dive location where Ocean Adventures Dive Co. of Marina del Rey reported him missing - and near the spot where the group had dived earlier in the day.
Carlock and three dive buddies had entered the water at about 8:45 a.m.
Carlock had problems equalizing the pressure in his ears and fell behind. He tried following his partners' bubbles, but he lost them.
He decided to end his dive after 15 minutes, but when he surfaced, he was 400 feet down current from an oil platform where the boat was anchored. He figured he couldn't make the up-current swim and decided to wait, blowing his whistle as loud as he could.
Carlock, a Santa Monica resident and spacecraft engineer for Boeing Satellite Systems, said he's dived about once a month since learning in 2002, but he hadn't gone out since December.
"I figured when the dive was over, they would realize I was missing and come looking for me," he said.
But they never came.
The group left that location and moved north to a shipwreck site six miles southeast of the entrance to the Port of Los Angeles, Coast Guard Petty Officer Collin Croft said.
The captain of the Sundiver, Ray Arntz, reported Carlock missing from the second dive location at 12:03 p.m., Croft said. The Coast Guard, the recreational diving instructors, Long Beach lifeguards and Los Angeles City Fire Department personnel searched for Carlock near the second dive location until hearing of his rescue in Orange County.
Arntz told officials that Dive Master Zacharias Araneta had accounted for all the divers before leaving the first location, Croft said.
Ocean Adventures Dive Co. owner Steve Ladd said Monday that he was figuring out what had happened and would seek to "turn a negative into a positive" by changing procedures, if needed. He declined further comment and could not be reached Tuesday.
Croft said he is determining if safety rules were violated.
"The Scouts definitely saved this man's life."
KB9WFK - 29 Apr 2004 18:07 GMT snip
> He turned his head and feet east, That must have been very uncomfortable.
kb9wfk
Larry Anta - 29 Apr 2004 20:47 GMT > Arntz told officials that Dive Master Zacharias Araneta had accounted for > all the divers before leaving the first location, Croft said. Guess he only learned to count to three.
Scott McFadden - 30 Apr 2004 14:29 GMT
> (I was just talking to a buddy about giving the Sundiver a try the next time > we went out - now I think not) Greg, given your charming and gracious personality I doubt anyone would leave you behind.
In any event, just how many divers does this boat take out?
It must be one of those really horrendous, pot-walloping, jam-packed, cattle boats Cal is so infamous for. As this is the only possible reason I can begin to understand why this incident could have happened.
> Arntz told officials that Dive Master Zacharias Araneta had accounted for > all the divers before leaving the first location, Croft said. This (soon to be former?) USCG Captain is going to learn to very expensive lesson.
"Never rely on a DM for anything, at all." -- SJM
William P.N. Smith - 30 Apr 2004 23:33 GMT >In any event, just how many divers does this boat take out? The cnn.com story said that he went on the first dive with THREE buddies.
 Signature William Smith ComputerSmiths Consulting, Inc. www.compusmiths.com
Scott McFadden - 01 May 2004 15:12 GMT > >In any event, just how many divers does this boat take out? > > The cnn.com story said that he went on the first dive with THREE > buddies. I am well aware of what "cnn" said. Unfortunately, they are plagued with ignorantly inaccurate, or at best naively misleading, "reporting".
A 54' boat certified for "up to 42 divers" is not going anywhere with only FOUR divers aboard. The crew could lose less money just leaving her tied up to the dock.
It's one thing to make a onetime, really dumb mistake (and be lucky enough to have no one seriously hurt or killed) like they did. Quite another to knowingly commit financial "hara-kiri".
http://sundiver.net/
Actually a pretty sharp looking boat (if limited to 12-15 divers). -- SJM
William P.N. Smith - 01 May 2004 16:23 GMT >> >In any event, just how many divers does this boat take out? http://tinyurl.com/3dfz4
/* "We anticipate that we will file a complaint for negligence against the captain. There is absolutely no question about that," said Lt. Cmdr. John Fassero, a senior Coast Guard investigator. [...] Capt. Ray Arntz is responsible for leaving Carlock despite a dive master's verbal roll call of all 20 passengers before leaving the first dive location, Fassero said.
"The buck stops with the captain," he said. */
So, there's your answer. Apparently he was in a buddy group of four, in a boat with 20 divers.
It's _still_ financial hari-kari to own a dive shop and either not know about several recent high profile cases of divers being left behind or not care enough to implement a token-based diver tracking system. Heck, DAN's system is free to business members, and that costs all of $125.
From http://sundiver.net/ /* While we are certified for 42 passengers, on day trips we will take a maximum of 26 divers and for overnight trips, 22 divers. */
 Signature William Smith ComputerSmiths Consulting, Inc. www.compusmiths.com
Scott McFadden - 02 May 2004 21:25 GMT
> It's _still_ financial hari-kari to own a dive shop and either not > know about several recent high profile cases of divers being left > behind or not care enough to implement a token-based diver tracking > system. Old Captains and sailors say that if you spend alot time on the sea, the sun starts to slowly dull your mind. (could never have been all the alcohol)
Maybe that's what happened to them, I know it's happened to me. -- SJM
Joe English - 01 May 2004 02:41 GMT > > [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > Greg, given your charming and gracious personality I doubt anyone > would leave you behind. I know this out of all the people I would leave behing the last of them would be - GREG! :-)
I mean that - Greg
p-boy - 04 May 2004 04:40 GMT "Dive Master Zacharias Araneta had accounted for all the divers before leaving the first location..."
If the skipper is supposed to check divers in and out of the water, what good is the Dive Master? The skipper is busy with his duties and MUST rely on the DM to do his duty and care for the divers. The DM blew it and so did the guy's buddies. If you seperate under water, you don't wait until the end of the dive to determine if your buddy made it back to the boat or not.
Way to go Boy Scouts!!!
Adam Helberg - 30 Apr 2004 01:20 GMT > Man Was Adrift After Boat Crew Forgot Him Maybe the divemaster assumed the diver decided to swim to shore or decided to do some fitness swimming?
CPFikes - 30 Apr 2004 14:29 GMT What I shake my head at is the dive buddies. They where the irresponcible ones, even more so than the divemaster. They failed to do the right thing on many points. Lesson learned...never dive with them again!!!
Greg Mossman - 01 May 2004 22:26 GMT > Lesson learned...never dive with them again!!! Yeah, that will teach them.
Rockinghorse Winner - 12 May 2004 07:28 GMT My favorite story about the boy scouts was one a work partner told me a number of years ago. He was driving up the Angeles Crest hwy with his gf behind him on his motorcycle, when an amorous mood hit them. They stopped, and hiked into the woods a distance and proceeded to drop trou. Well, they were having a very nice time there in the woods, when they heard some rustling in the brush. Just as they were reaching nirvana, they heard a prepubescent voice call out, 'ooh, look!', and an entire troop of boyscouts rushed into the clearing.
What's the boyscout motto, again -- always prepared?!!
CUL8R
R*Horse
www.sonic.net/~lkokot
"Take a look behind you - upstream - now you begin to recognize this country, don't you?"
"Yes, I do recognize it now. It is the most wonderful thing I ever heard of; by a long shot the most wonderful - and unexpected."
Mark Twain Life on the Mississippi
|
|
|